Refutation of al-Qaradawi
1st: Allah provides bought Muslims to deal rightly with non-Muslims so to end up being kind to them on the basis of the verse in the Quran:
a€?Allah cannot prohibit one deal rightly and kindly with those that struggled perhaps not against yourself on account of faith and decided not to generate a person from your very own property. Verily, Allah enjoys people that target assets.a€? ( al-Mumtahina : 8)
By citing this verse, al-Qaradawi phrases that it’s authorized to congratulate non-Muslims on the trips simply because this constitutes being kind and simply for. But to-draw this conclusion because of this verse is a blunder because are varieties and merely to other individuals is absolutely not permissible in case calls for disobedience to Allah. As being the Prophet i·? said: a€?There is no behavior to virtually individual whether it includes sin; compliance is only as and is suitable and correct.a€? 2 in cases like this, there is certainly crystal clear disobedience to Allah once non-Muslims commit functions of shirk and sin while the Muslim congratulates these people on those times in which those functions tend to be fully committed.
Other: The Prophet i·? bought Asmaa€™ bint Abi Bakr, once the girl polytheist mom come and went to their, by mentioning: a€?Keep good interaction with all your mom.a€? 3 once more, that is a hadith that’s `amm (basic) and mutlaq (total), therefore, they says almost nothing about vacation. In addition, it’s a loan application of a€?behave together in this world please.a€? In order to apply this verse to indicate that really permissible to congratulate and/or participate in non-Muslim vacation will be contrary some other Islamic texts, like if Allah purchased people not to tune in to all of our people if he or she get you to make serves of shirk as well as other sins:
a€?in case these people endeavor along with you to help you join in activity with me at night other people that which you have no information, consequently follow them definitely not, but respond with these people in the world kindly.a€? (Luqman: 15).
In discussing the true reason for the versea€™s insight, the students of tafsir mentioned it was announced in the case of Saa€?ad ibn Abi Waqas, whose mother bought him to obey her and disbelieve in Islam. Upon this, Allah revealed the aforementioned verse ordering most of the believers as acquiescent their people except in the case that complex disbelief or shirk. 4
Last: Yes, Allah possess enabled Muslims to enjoy through the protein of people regarding the ebook and wed of their womenfolk. The issue is: If a Muslim marries these a woman, subsequently how would it be feasible for him to reside in harmony, comfort, and really like along with her although it is not congratulating the or the girl relatives on their holidays? This type of qiyas (analogical thought) was blemished because one of the major pillars of qiyas lacks, and that’s the a€?illah (operative result). 5 The a€?illah in this instance is the fact that the Jews together with the Christians need a Divine Scripture, which entails that Muslims can consume using chicken and marry from their site. But will never be allowable for everyone to make qiyas with this as the ruling is actually khass (particular) or muqayyad (constrained) to these types of functions. On the list of policies for producing an allegorical explanation (taa€™wil) would be that khass and muqayyad may not be available for additional interpretations. 6 Furthermore, qiyas cannot staying as rich in power given that the defined evidences or ijmaa€?. What this means is which final result of qiyas is in conformation aided by the objectives of this Sharia€?a to ascertain its concord on your Islamic messages. 7 plus in the case of congratulating and indulging during the vacations on the non-Muslims, an ijmaa€? is reported on the ban by students like for example Ibn al-Qayyim, therefore, rendering this qiyas invalid.
Fourth: al-Qaradawi furthermore noted that the verse in which Allah claims, a€?when you’re welcomed with a greeting, welcome in return as to what surpasses it, or (at least) return it similarly.a€? (al-Nisaa€™: 86). Once again, using passages within the Quran for functions besides whatever they are suitable for inside their context is actually a flawed system. This verse is particular inside welcoming that is definitely common among Muslims, which is certainly to convey salam a€?alaykum or something like it. If noting this verse, every one of the scholars of tafsir note it regarding saying salam a€?alaykum, and do not require caused it to be general to add various types of hello. 8
Abdullah container Bayyah/Hamza Yusuf
Trash Bayyah 14 in the reserve, Sinaa€?at al-Fatwa wa Fiqh al-Aqalliyyat, offers the same proofs and concepts as al-Qaraa??awi, but this individual includes this comments:
The Scholars posses disagreed upon this dilemma of congratulating the non-Muslims (within their festivals). From inside the madhhab of Imam Ahmad there are three thoughts: a) it’s banned, b) actually disliked and c) it is permissible. It is primarily the final thoughts (of permissibility) that Sheikh Taqi al-Din Ibn Taymiyyah decided on because of its maslaa??ah (as a whole good) referring to the view that we select as well Myladyboydate support. Therefore, it’s allowable to congratulate them (non-Muslims), to console them for their sadness, and also take a look at the company’s ill. Al-Mardawi has estimated every one of these narrations in the guide, al-Ina??af. And what is pointed out within for the other publications in regard to Ibn Taymiyyah may not be in arrangement along with his established suggestions. 15